A Federal High Court has delayed a ruling on a tax dispute between Nigeria‚Äôs Liquefied Natural Gas Company (NLNG) and the Nigerian Maritime Administration and Safety Agency (NIMASA) over taxes till Monday, extending a deadlock which an economist said has resulted in a loss of gas export worth $22 million a day.
Since June 21, NIMASA has barred LNG cargoes from entering or leaving the loading bay at the Bonny terminal in the Niger Delta because it says NLNG is not paying a 3 per cent levy, from which the NLNG argues it is exempt.
A report by Channels Television Saturday said the parties were in court in Lagos on Friday to try to resolve the dispute over the lawfulness of the blockade and the levies, which NLNG spokesman, Kudo Eresia-Eke, had earlier said he hoped would be resolved. The court adjourned the case until Monday.
The Nigerian National Petroleum Corporation (NNPC) owns 49 per cent of NLNG with Shell holding 25.6 per cent, Total 15 per cent and Eni 10.4 per cent.
NLNG accounted for 9 per cent of Nigeria‚Äôs exports in 2012, said economist Bismarck Rewane, CEO of Lagos-based consultancy Financial Derivatives, or roughly $8.1 billion a year, a quarter of Nigeria‚Äôs federal fiscal budget for 2013.
‚ÄúThat‚Äôs about $155 million a week, of which 51 per cent belongs to the Nigerian government,‚Äù he said. ‚ÄúThat is a lot of money to the finance ministry.‚Äù
NLNG declared force majeure on gas exports on June 28 because of the blockade.
Mr Ereia-Eke declined to give figures for NLNG losses, and finance ministry officials were not immediately available.
NIMASA spokesman Isichei Osamgbi said the agency was seeking cumulative levies of $158 million.
‚ÄúOur business is not to cause any crisis to the gas sector. We just insist on our dues. Why shouldn‚Äôt they pay the levies that are applicable to anybody?‚Äù he said.
NLNG argues that the act that established it makes it exempt, but Osamgbi said the exemptions expired after the first year of profit, following a 5-year holiday.
A shipping source said NIMASA already charges LNG tankers $600,000 per berth to load at the NLNG bay, four times higher than the average among the highest fees of any LNG port.
NLNG says a court order was issued on June 18 preventing NIMASA from blockading the port until a resolution was found, but the maritime agency denies that.
Buyers of Nigeria‚Äôs LNG include Spain‚Äôs Repsol, Italy‚Äôs Enel, Britain‚Äôs BG Group France‚Äôs GDF Suez and Portugal‚Äôs Galp.